Don the Beachcomber's Planter's Punch

Don the Beachcomber's Planter's Punch

Donn Beach's 1937 masterpiece that transformed the rustic Jamaican punch into a complex tiki classic with three distinct rums, falernum, grenadine, and Angostura bitters.

28%

ABV

hard

Difficulty

collins

Glass

History & Heritage

Ernest Raymond Beaumont Gantt (later Donn Beach) encountered the simple Jamaican Planter's Punch during his Caribbean travels in the 1920s-30s, specifically at the Myrtle Bank Hotel in Kingston. When he opened Don the Beachcomber in Hollywood in 1934, he transformed this rustic "one of sour, two of sweet, three of strong, four of weak" formula into a sophisticated "Rhum Rhapsody." The 1937 recipe, discovered through Jeff "Beachbum" Berry's meticulous research of Donn's original bartenders' notes, became the template for countless tiki cocktails. By blending three distinct rums and layering complex sweeteners and spices, Donn created more than a drink—he crafted the foundation of modern tiki culture and elevated American mixology from simple cocktails to intricate, multi-dimensional creations.

Ingredients

Quality ingredients make all the difference. Each component plays a crucial role.

Method

Technique transforms ingredients into something extraordinary.

1

Add all ingredients to a blender with ¾ cup of crushed ice

2

Flash blend for no more than 5 seconds to chill and integrate

3

Perform a 'dirty dump' by pouring entire contents into a tall Collins glass

4

Top with additional crushed ice to fill the glass

5

Garnish with a fresh mint sprig, slapped to release oils

6

Serve immediately with a straw

Glassware

collins

Served over crushed ice in a tall Collins glass (12-14 oz)

Garnish

Mint sprig

Slapped to release essential oils

Pineapple wedge

Fresh wedge

Optional

Cocktail cherry

Maraschino cherry

Optional

Flavor Journey

Every great cocktail tells a story through its flavors. Here's the sensory experience you can expect.

6

Sweet

out of 10

4

Sour

out of 10

2

Bitter

out of 10

7

Strong

out of 10

Master's Tips

Professional insights to elevate your craft

Use only fresh-squeezed lime juice—bottled will ruin the drink

Flash blend for exactly 5 seconds to avoid over-dilution

The three-rum blend is crucial—don't substitute with a single rum

Serve immediately after preparation to maintain proper texture

Use high-quality, real pomegranate grenadine, not artificial versions

Variations & Riffs

Classic cocktails inspire countless variations. Here are some popular riffs on the Don the Beachcomber's Planter's Punch.

Don's Own Planter's

Major Variation

Simpler variation using lemon juice instead of lime, honey mix as sweetener, topped with club soda.

Changes
Fresh Lime JuiceFresh Lemon Juice(0.5 oz)
Simple SyrupHoney Syrup(0.5 oz)
Club Soda(2 oz)

Don's Beach Planter

Major Variation

Complex 1937 variation with pineapple juice, passion fruit syrup, and Cognac alongside Rhum Agricole.

Changes
Fresh Pineapple Juice(1 oz)
Passion Fruit Syrup(0.5 oz)
Cognac(0.5 oz)

Colonel Beach's Plantation Punch

Major Variation

Features Pernod which combines with Angostura bitters to create one of Donn's secret spice combinations.

Changes
Pernod(3 drops)

Extra Tart Version

Minor Tweak

Increases lime juice to a full ounce for those who prefer a tarter profile.

Changes
Fresh Lime Juice:0.5 oz1 oz

Spice-Forward Version

Minor Tweak

Slightly increases falernum for a more pronounced spice note.

Changes
Falernum:1 barspoon1.5 barspoon

More to Explore

If you enjoyed this cocktail, these similar creations might capture your interest.