Smoky Nail
A bold variation of the classic Rusty Nail where smoky Islay Scotch whisky replaces the traditional Highland malt, adding layers of peat smoke, brine, and medicinal complexity to the honeyed sweetness of Drambuie.
34%
ABV
easy
Difficulty
rocks
Glass
History & Heritage
“The Smoky Nail emerged organically during the craft cocktail renaissance as bartenders and whisky enthusiasts discovered the captivating interplay between peated Islay Scotch and Drambuie's honeyed complexity. This variation transforms the familiar Rusty Nail template by introducing the maritime, medicinal, and smoky character of Islay whiskies, creating a more contemplative and assertive drinking experience.”
Ingredients
Quality ingredients make all the difference. Each component plays a crucial role.
1.5 oz
0.5 oz
Method
Technique transforms ingredients into something extraordinary.
Add both ingredients to a rocks glass filled with large ice cubes
Stir gently to combine and chill
Garnish with expressed lemon twist
Glassware
Served over ice in a rocks glass
Garnish
Expressed lemon twist
Flavor Journey
Every great cocktail tells a story through its flavors. Here's the sensory experience you can expect.
Sweet
out of 10
Sour
out of 10
Bitter
out of 10
Strong
out of 10
Master's Tips
Professional insights to elevate your craft
Use a moderately peated Islay Scotch—overly aggressive expressions can overwhelm the Drambuie
Stir gently to integrate without over-diluting the complex flavors
Large ice cubes provide proper chilling while maintaining the drink's strength
The lemon twist adds brightness that cuts through the rich, smoky elements
Variations & Riffs
Classic cocktails inspire countless variations. Here are some popular riffs on the Smoky Nail.
Equal Parts
1:1 ratio of Islay Scotch to Drambuie for a sweeter, more liqueur-forward profile.
Changes
Extra Smoky
Uses heavily peated Islay whisky like Octomore or Supernova for maximum smoke.
Changes
Highland Smoke
Uses lightly peated Highland or Speyside whisky for subtler smoke character.
Changes
More to Explore
If you enjoyed this cocktail, these similar creations might capture your interest.
Clavo Ahumado
A bold and sophisticated modern classic that brilliantly reimagines the iconic Rusty Nail by substituting Scotch whisky with the earthy, smoky character of mezcal.
Donald Sutherland
Canada's answer to the classic Rusty Nail, substituting Scotch with the distinctively spicy and smooth character of Canadian rye whisky.
Rusty Nail
Scotch whisky and Drambuie. A simple, honeyed Highland cocktail.